Life Group Discussion Guide
Judges 11 – Jephthah: When Striving Breaks You
🧭 Opening Prompt
- Share a time when you felt like an outsider or under pressure to prove yourself.
- Or: What’s something you’ve worked hard to earn approval for—at work, in family, or even in faith?
📖 Read the Passage: Judges 11:1–11, 29–40
Context Summary:
Jephthah, the son of a prostitute, is driven out of his family and becomes a leader of outcasts. Later, the same elders who rejected him ask for his help. He agrees—after negotiating a deal—and makes a reckless vow that leads to tragedy.
💬 Key Sermon Quotes for Reflection
“Jephthah was a wounded man trying to prove himself – and it broke him.”
“If you cannot receive grace, you’ll try to earn what only God can give—and you may destroy what you love most.”
“We’re not just guilty because of what we’ve done; we carry shame for who we think we are.”
❓ Discussion Questions
1. The Root of Shame
- How does Jephthah’s story show the deep power of shame?
- Where do you see shame (not just guilt) shaping people’s behaviour today?
2. Performance-Based Identity
- In what ways did Jephthah try to earn his identity or worth?
- Where do you see performance or striving creeping into your own spiritual life?
3. Grace vs Bargaining
- Why do you think Jephthah made a vow after the Spirit of the Lord came upon him (v. 29)?
- What does that say about how little he understood grace?
4. Cultural Pressure
- How might our culture (or even the church) unintentionally reinforce a “works-based” identity?
- What are signs that someone is living out of grace vs out of striving?
5. Receiving Grace
- What’s difficult about receiving grace rather than trying to earn it?
- What would it look like for you to live more fully in the freedom and joy of grace?
🧠 Deeper Reflection
“Shame says: I am something wrong.
Grace says: I am deeply loved.”
- Are there any hidden areas of your life where shame still speaks louder than grace?
- What patterns (control, perfectionism, isolation, over-achievement, etc.) might be rooted in unhealed shame?
🙏 Prayer Time
Use these prompts to pray as a group:
- “Lord, help us see where we’re striving instead of resting in your grace.”
- “Help us to trust Your love and stop negotiating with You.”
- “Heal the places in us still shaped by shame.”
You might also invite people to pray silently and then share one word or image that came to mind during the silence.
🧱 Practical Application for the Week
- Practice receiving grace this week—when you fail, when you succeed, and when you feel unseen.
- Choose one activity you normally strive in (e.g. work, parenting, serving) and do it without trying to impress anyone.
- Read and reflect on Romans 8:1–4 or Matthew 11:28–30 each day.
🪧 Optional Extra: Communion Reflection
As we take the bread and cup, remember—this is not a performance review.
This is God’s table of grace.
Come freely. Come joyfully. Leave your striving behind.